This is actually the exact list that I sent my mom so hopefully I'll have some of these things to post reviews about after Christmas!
Horze Jeffery Saddle Pad
These are currently my favorite saddle pads I have the cool mint green one.
They come in all sorts of cool colors but even more importantly they come in pony size!! They are also reasonably priced at $27.95.
Horze Polo Wraps
With Katai's color changing to grey it's time to get some matching polo wraps. These are reasonably priced at $18.95 and come in Grey which is actually a tough color to find in polo wraps.
You can never have too many socks. I have some cheap riding socks for summer and some ski socks on my list, all are under $20.
Swanky Saddlery Monogram Bridle Tag
These Wither and Withers horse treats are my absolute favorite horse treats. They are designed for insulin resistant horses with almost no sugar added and are so good that I occasionally snack on them. As an added bonus they are small and neat so they don't make a huge mess in my pockets. They are fairly expensive for horse treats at around $20 depending on where you shop but there are a ton in a bag so they last a long time.
These are adorable and very reasonable at $15.00.
Swanky Saddlery Brush Monogram
Higher Standards Saddle Soap
I've been wanting some of this stuff for a long time and it finally made it onto my list this year. Very reasonable at $14.95 per container.